My Cartoonist Guide

17 комментариев к “My Cartoonist Guide”

Раздел комментариев ниже предназначен только для обсуждения, для новых запросов используйте Discord.

1. relatively mature written work. when i read the comments, i was surprised because the overall tone of the writing is not childish. the pace of indeed slow but several years passed in the story. the manga i recognized are i's | hikaru no go | death note | slam dunk | stein's gate. not sure about all the other titles mentioned. the mc has a cheat, but unlike the other couple of works of the same type i have read before, the mc did not bulldoze his way to fame and fortune. he basically spent most of his days in front of a drawing board. despite having the "memory capsule" of all the manga in the original world, he still has to make a lot of adjustments. his physical strength also did not receive any boost. the plot is relatively strong and weak at the same time. the author wrote in detail about many things but also failed to allot enough space for other related things making the plot weak. like how he went on about the storyboard and drawing skills but basically did not mention anything about typesetting and onomatopoeia. anyway, for some reason, i did get addicted in reading this but i also would not give a high rating. like i mentioned earlier, it's very descriptive in some things but also careless about many. i would not have minded if the author continued the story though. especially when the mc is starting to dab on games. but yeah, it did kinda get boringly repetitive.

   Reply

2. forgot to mention fullmetal alchemist.

   Reply

3. also one of the biggest highlights is that there is no china numbawan here. even anything subtle. nothing. although i still can't get over using district 11 instead of other aliases like sakura country or something. well, better than island country? nah, just as bad imo. lol. america is mi country. another thing that bothered me is how they do not hire translators most of the time, and the mc's personal editors have to do that job. so weird. the female editor had to do most of the comic translations (chinese to japanese and vice versa). i mean, they should be able to hire someone more capable, either professional or from universities. there is also the matter with the contract with the japanese publisher. this seriously needs a professional, no? i wonder if i still forgot something...

   Reply

4. This is a fast food novel pretending to be a restaurant novel. It has all the characteristics of fast food: Faceslapping, schemes, stupid characters and irrelevant sub-plots. However, it's a very slow paced novel. I'm in chapter 100s and he still hasn't finished 50% of the manga he is writing.the manga has 15 to 17ish volumes but why he's still in volume 3 for God's sake. Another thing is that there are too many irreverent sub-plots. Like just draw the Mangas man. One sub-plot point is videogame game art which is not related to manga at all. The most annoying thing about this is that there are too many schemes. Promotion this promotion that. Just fu**king draw.

   Reply

5. 𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐲 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 S𝐢𝐭𝐞 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 O𝐧𝐥𝐲 𝐑-𝟏𝟖 𝐍𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐥: 𝐧𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐥𝐫𝟏𝟖.𝐜𝐨𝐦

   Reply

6. this novel is similar with i just want to draw comic, typical mc receive system about manga plagiarize japanese manga & anime then mc become popular leading some envy & hatred from other people, some arrogant senior mangaka come ask to be face slap by mc, rinse & repeat. after arrogant mangaka no longer could fight against mc, mc face slap the profiteer, capitalist of manga industry rinse & repeat. that's the gist of this novel, don't expect any harem though since mc only marry with 1 girl mangaka.

   Reply

7. Thank you. ! 🙏💕

   Reply

8. Only read this story if you want to be angry, and with an extreme desire to punch the author in the face.

   Reply

9. no idea how & why since you didn't tell us the cause of it

   Reply

См. другие 8 комментариев